Welcome to Carlo's Grocery
At Carlo's Grocery, we celebrate the rich heritage of Italian-American cuisine in Brooklyn. Established in a cozy corner of Bensonhurst, this beloved eatery prides itself on serving homemade dishes that evoke memories of family gatherings. Customers rave about our generously portioned sandwiches, from the mouthwatering grilled chicken and mozzarella to the eggplant parm that leaves taste buds singing. The heartfelt service from our friendly owners adds to the charm, making every visit feel like home. Diners note the freshness and quality of our ingredients, ensuring that each bite is a delightful reminder of classic Italian cooking. Welcome to Carlo's Grocery—your go-to for comfort food done right.
-
1983 52nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11204 Hotline: (718) 253-0322
Welcome to Carlo's Grocery, a cherished gem nestled in the heart of Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. Located at 1983 52nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11204, this delightful eatery takes you back to the days when traditional Italian fare filled the neighborhood with warmth and nostalgia. With roots that run deep, Carlo's Grocery isn't just a place to grab a meal; it's a destination that evokes memories of home-cooked goodness and the comforting embrace of family.
From the moment you step inside Carlo's Grocery, you're greeted with friendly smiles and an inviting atmosphere that feels just like home. The owners treat every customer like family, ensuring a genuine experience that makes you want to return time and again. As customer Rebecca D. exclaims, "I've been eating here forever. Best little place ever!" It’s a sentiment echoed by many who have come to rely on Carlo's for their delicious meals.
One of the standout features of Carlo's Grocery is their generous portion sizes, making every meal a fantastic value. Randall M. famously remarked on the immense grilled chicken and mozzarella sandwich that "could feed two not very hungry individuals," all for just $14. This pragmatic approach to dining doesn’t sacrifice quality; each bite bursts with fresh, homemade flavors that transport you back to family gatherings around the dinner table.
The menu at Carlo's offers a wide array of homestyle dishes, each prepared with care and affection. With everything from mouthwatering sandwiches to classic pasta sides, there's something for everyone. Customers rave about the eggplant parmesan, which Len O. describes as "to die for." It’s the kind of food that makes you reminisce about your late mother's cooking, as noted by Aniello D.. The atmosphere is casual, but the quality of food is anything but; each dish is crafted to deliver an exceptional flavor experience.
Moreover, Carlo's Grocery is known for their swift service, which is especially appreciated during those busy lunchtime hours. Regulars like Andy T. sing praises of the excellent food and the warm, welcoming staff. Testimonials highlight not just the food but the community spirit that Carlo's fosters—a place where everyone feels at home.
In times of celebration, Carlo's Grocery is a go-to spot for special occasions. Whether it’s a birthday celebration, as experienced by Anthony T. and his wife, or an impromptu family gathering, the meals crafted here bring people together, creating cherished memories over plates filled with incredible flavors.
If you’re looking for a place that embodies the essence of Italian-American cuisine, look no further than Carlo's Grocery. With its unbeatable mix of quality food, generous portions, and a welcoming environment, this neighborhood stalwart promises not just a meal, but an experience that will leave you longing for more. Don't let the humble storefront fool you; step inside, and you'll discover that Carlo's is a treasure trove of taste waiting to be explored.
To experience Carlo's Grocery, call them at (718) 253-0322 or simply drop by and taste the magic for yourself. You won’t be disappointed!
I've been eating here forever. Best little place ever, the food is always amazing! Wish I still lived nearby.
Carlo's Grocery is a remnant from the days when Italians roamed the neighborhood. This is a bare bones operation, but if you need a sandwich don't hesitate to try them. I ordered a grilled Chicken and Mozzarella sandwich, and I took it to go. The sandwich was large and very fresh. It cost only $14.00 for a sandwich that could feed two not very hungry individuals. I'll be back!
Great secret in Bensonhurst great food homemade delicious and will always go there !!! Great service lots too choose from and u won't be disappointed at all at Carlos grocery
Great small homestyle Food. excellent reminds me of my late mother and father Cooking highly recommend.
It was my wife's birthday. I told her whatever you wanna do let me know she responded I feel like having a great meal and spending time with family so I guess you're gonna call up Carlos and place a order and we'll just sit down and relax and enjoy my birthday, the food was spectacular as usual so my wife enjoyed her birthday. Thank you Dom you did it again.
Where has Carlos been all my life. Im so happy that I found ya. Excellent food/service- the nicest people!
This is absolutely the best place to get a hot or cold sandwich as well as a dinner ( with pasta side). Get the medium size because the large is a completely huge sandwich good for 2 hungry guys. Order your sandwich, like eggplant parm to die for, and wait patiently for it to be made. You will not be disappointed. Don't let the front of the deli fool you, the food is amazing. 5 stars baby!!!
Food always fresh and delicious. The owners are very friendly and care about you. Mom and pop places are always the best.
Amazing food good people Everything is wow And fresh sells out fast the shrimp sandwich